Research - The Musical Connection

Evidence-based progression

Our research providing evidence and learnings for enhanced LGBTQ+ inclusion in (arts) education

Our mixed-methods research across the four participating European institutions provides evidence for effective enhancement for inclusion within a schoolsystem

Drag cursor to create magic...
Swipe to create magic...

Research Methodology

Quantitative component

Three-wave longitudinal survey design measuring changes in attitudes, knowledge, and school climate.

  • n = 847 students across 4 institutions
  • 3 measurements: Baseline (Sept 2023), Midpoint (Feb 2024), Final (June 2024)
  • Validated scales: LGBTQ+ knowledge, attitude toward inclusion, perceived safety, empathy
  • Analysis: Paired t-tests, regression, subgroup comparisons

Qualitative component

In-depth exploration of experiences, barriers, and mechanisms of change.

  • 42 student interviews (LGBTQ+ and ally students)
  • 18 teacher focus groups across institutions
  • 8 administrator interviews with school leaders
  • Analysis: Thematic analysis, constant comparison method

Expert review panel

Two external experts provided independent evaluation of curriculum and research:

Dr. Karen Walker

University of Leeds, UK | Expert in LGBTQ+ education and school climate

"Methodologically sound with appropriate mixed-methods design. The musical theater approach is innovative and well-justified."

Bas van den Berg

Former Chair, COC Netherlands | LGBTQ+ Rights Advocate

"Addresses a critical gap in VET education. The emphasis on safety and student agency is commendable."

Featured Researcher

TK

Dr. Tessa M.L. Kaufman

University of Utrecht

View Full Profile →

Masterclass Contribution

Dr. Kaufman delivered a masterclass on February 26, 2024 at Lentiz Floracollege for The Musical Connection project, sharing research insights on:

  • Challenges experienced by LGBTQ+ youth, teachers, and schools
  • Evidence-based interventions to stimulate inclusion and acceptance
  • Creating safer educational environments for gender diverse students

Key Research: Microaggressions Study

Dr. Kaufman's research examined sexual and gender identity-based microaggressions among Dutch SGM (sexual and gender minority) youth through two daily diary studies:

Study 1

N=90 participants
Average age: 17.64 years

Study 2

N=393 participants
Average age: 18.36 years

Key Findings:
  • • Lesbian women and bisexual youth less likely to report microaggressions than gay youth
  • • Gender minority youth more likely to report familial microaggressions and invalidation
  • • Youth assigned male at birth less likely to report invalidation than those assigned female
  • • Significant variability in frequency across 16 types of microaggressions

Types of Microaggressions Identified:

• Heterosexist/transphobic terminology
• Physical threat or harassment
• Familial microaggressions
• Denial of body privacy
• Invalidation of LGBTQ identity
• Systemic/environmental microaggressions
• Threatening behaviors
• And 9 more categories...

Why This Matters for TMC: This research provides the empirical foundation for The Musical Connection's approach. By understanding the daily microaggressions SGM youth face, we designed interventions (like musical theater pedagogy) that create safe distance, build empathy, and reduce these harmful experiences.

Theoretical Framework

The Genderbread Person Model: Understanding Gender as a Spectrum

What is the Genderbread Person?

The Musical Connection uses the Genderbread Person model to help educators and students understand gender as a spectrum rather than a binary. This visual tool breaks down the complex, diverse, and fluid nature of gender into four interconnected continuums.

🧑 Interactive Genderbread Person Resource

Explore Interactive Model →

1. Gender Identity

How you identify internally

Male, female, combination of both, or neither (non-binary). This is your personal and internal sense of self.

  • • Man, woman, genderqueer, agender
  • • Doesn't depend on assigned sex at birth
  • • Personal, deeply felt sense

2. Gender Expression

How you present externally

Behavior, clothing, mannerisms, voice. Can vary regardless of assigned sex at birth. Fluid and contextual.

  • • Masculine, feminine, androgynous
  • • Can change based on situation
  • • Not fixed or binary

3. Biological Sex

Physical characteristics

Chromosomes, hormones, reproductive organs. Not strictly binary—intersex individuals exist. Complex spectrum of characteristics.

  • • Male, female, intersex variations
  • • Biological diversity exists
  • • Not always aligned with identity

4. Attraction

Who you're drawn to

Heterosexual to homosexual spectrum. Bisexual, pansexual, asexual orientations. Romantic vs. sexual attraction can differ.

  • • Sexual and romantic orientations
  • • Can be fluid over time
  • • Independent of gender identity

🔑 Key Concepts

  • These four continuums are interconnected and intersecting
  • Gender is complex, diverse, and fluid — not fixed categories
  • Individuals may not fit traditional categories
  • Gender identity and expression can change over time
  • Binary thinking is limiting — gender exists on multiple spectrums

Why This Model for VET Education?

  • Helps break down stereotypes and assumptions
  • Provides concrete framework for discussing abstract concepts
  • Visual/interactive tool accessible for diverse learners
  • Normalizes gender diversity as part of human variation
  • Supports safer, more inclusive classroom environments

Classroom Application

Use the Genderbread Person as:

  • 💬 Discussion starter about identity and diversity
  • 📊 Visual aid during LGBTQ+ education lessons
  • 🪞 Tool for self-reflection and understanding
  • 🧠 Framework for challenging binary thinking

Educator Tip: Start with the Genderbread Person before diving into musical theater exercises. It gives students a common language and framework for understanding the identities they'll be exploring through performance.

Key Research Findings

Finding 1: Significant Knowledge Gains

Students showed substantial increases in LGBTQ+ knowledge across all measurement points.

+42%
Increase in LGBTQ+ terminology knowledge
+38%
Understanding of discrimination impacts
p < .001
Statistical significance

Method: 20-item knowledge test, administered at all three time points (n=847)

Finding 2: Improved Empathy & Attitudes

Musical theater approach significantly increased empathy and positive attitudes toward LGBTQ+ peers.

+51%
Increase in empathy scores (musical theater group)
+28%
Increase in standard curriculum group
2.3x
More effective than lecture-based approach

Method: Toronto Empathy Questionnaire (TEQ) + custom LGBTQ+ attitude scale, quasi-experimental comparison

Finding 3: Safer School Climate

LGBTQ+ students reported feeling significantly safer and more included after curriculum implementation.

+47%
LGBTQ+ students feeling "safe at school"
-35%
Reported harassment incidents
+62%
Students willing to report discrimination

Method: School Climate Survey (adapted from GLSEN), incident reports, student interviews (n=42)

Finding 4: Teacher Confidence Increased

Educators reported greater confidence and competence in teaching LGBTQ+ content after using the curriculum.

+58%
Teachers feeling "confident" teaching LGBTQ+ topics
92%
Would recommend curriculum to colleagues
+44%
Perceived institutional support for inclusion

Method: Teacher surveys (n=38), focus groups (n=18), implementation journals

Statistical Analysis Summary

Outcome VariableBaseline Mean (SD)Final Mean (SD)Effect Size (Cohen's d)p-value
LGBTQ+ Knowledge12.3 (3.4)17.5 (2.8)1.67< .001
Empathy (TEQ)42.1 (8.2)51.3 (7.5)1.18< .001
Inclusive Attitudes3.4 (1.1)4.2 (0.9)0.81< .001
Perceived Safety (LGBTQ+)2.8 (1.3)4.1 (1.0)1.12< .001
Allyship Intentions3.1 (1.2)4.3 (0.8)1.19< .001

Interpretation Note

All effect sizes are considered large (d > 0.8) by Cohen's standards, indicating substantial practical significance beyond statistical significance.

Scales: Knowledge (0-20), TEQ (0-64), Attitudes & Safety (1-5 Likert), Allyship (1-5 Likert)

Qualitative Themes from Interviews

Theme 1: "Safe Distance" of Musical Theater

Students and teachers highlighted how musical theater created emotional distance that made sensitive topics approachable.

"I could explore being gay through my character without feeling like I was being judged personally. It was liberating." — Student, 18
"Students who usually shut down during LGBTQ+ discussions were fully engaged when we did theater exercises." — Teacher

Theme 2: Empathy Through Embodiment

Physically embodying different identities through movement and voice fostered deeper empathy than discussion alone.

"When I had to perform as a trans character, I really had to think about what that experience would feel like." — Student, 19
"Musical theater forces you to step into someone else's shoes—literally and metaphorically." — Teacher

Theme 3: Community Building

Collaborative performance projects created bonds across differences and reduced social fragmentation.

"Working on the musical together, we became a real team. Didn't matter who was LGBTQ+ or straight." — Student, 17
"The performance created a shared experience that transcended individual differences." — School Leader

Theme 4: Visibility Matters

LGBTQ+ students felt validated seeing their experiences represented in curriculum and performance.

"For the first time in school, I saw stories like mine. It made me feel like I existed, like I mattered." — Student, 20
"Representation isn't just nice to have—it's essential for LGBTQ+ student wellbeing." — Teacher

Publications & Presentations

Peer-Reviewed Journal Article (Forthcoming)

"Musical Theater as Pedagogy for LGBTQ+ Inclusion in Vocational Education: A Mixed-Methods Evaluation"

Journal of LGBTQ Youth (under review, 2025)

Conference Presentation

"The Musical Connection: Evidence-Based Approaches to LGBTQ+ Inclusion in European VET"

European Association for Research on Learning and Instruction (EARLI), August 2024

Policy Brief

"Creating Inclusive VET Institutions: Lessons from The Musical Connection Project"

Erasmus+ Dissemination Platform, 2025

Final Project Report

"The Musical Connection Final Report: Comprehensive evaluation of curriculum implementation across four partner institutions"

Available via Erasmus+ Project Results Platform, October 2025

Open Access Commitment

All research outputs are made available under open access licenses. Data can be requested for academic research purposes (anonymized to protect participant confidentiality).

Accessing Research Data

For Researchers & Academics

We support open science and data sharing. Anonymized datasets, code books, analysis scripts, and supplementary materials available for qualified researchers.

Available Data:

  • • Survey data (anonymized, n=847)
  • • Interview transcripts (coded)
  • • Focus group summaries
  • • Incident reports (aggregated)
  • • Curriculum materials & lesson plans

Requirements:

  • • Academic/research affiliation
  • • Clear research purpose
  • • Ethical approval from institution
  • • Data sharing agreement
  • • Acknowledgment in publications

For Educators & Practitioners

Access research summaries, infographics, and practice-focused briefings designed for non-academic audiences.

Research Summary (4 pages) Infographic: Key Findings Practice Brief: Applying Research Video: Research Explainer

Collaborate with Our Research

Request data access, explore collaborations, or learn more about our research methodology.